I would like you to imagine the following scene – this actually happened last week in a school in Purley. A little boy aged 7yrs suddenly burst into his class room wildly waving his arms about and enthusiastically announced, “Breaking news, Santa Claus doesn’t exist!” Well you can imagine the result, 27 sobbing, inconsolable infant school children. My natural reaction on hearing this tale was a desire to say to Malachi, for that ironically was the child’s name, what do you mean Santa Claus doesn’t exist? Now my reason for wanting to do this is twofold – firstly, I have a pathological hate for dogmatic statements and feel obliged to immediately and forcefully put the opposite point of view. Secondly, I happen to believe that myths have important things to tell us and although they may not be factually accurate, though usually they have some basis in fact, they are actually conveyers of truth. I would therefore have to point out to our errant conveyer of ill news that Santa Claus is in fact based on someone who existed, St Nicholas, a fourth century Bishop, who was in part responsible along with a lot of other Bishops for the creed we say during our worship and who was also particularly generous to the poor of his day. I would further suggest that embracing the faith he helped to articulate in the writing of the Creed and emulating his generosity is not a bad idea. So in that sense Santa Claus did exist and still exists as an image and a spur to faith and Christian action. Not that that would probably be of any comfort to the sobbing infants of class two who would probably, like Malachi, have a rather more concrete take on the subject.
Of course young Malachi is not unique in his desire to debunk commonly treasured Christmas myths and practices. Philip Stubbes a 16th Centenary Protestant Minister wrote the following about Christmas. 'More mischief is that time committed than in all the year besides ... What dicing and carding, what eating and drinking, what banqueting and feasting is then used ... to the great dishonour of God and the impoverishing of the realm.' In the year 1644 Parliament actually past an act banning Christmas celebrations as it was regarded by the Puritans as being a wasteful indulgence which threatened basic Christian beliefs. Needless to say the idea didn’t catch on and Christmas with all its excesses re-emerged at the time of the Restoration of the Monarchy.
At the risk of being a bit of a Malachi myself I feel obliged to point out that for the first four centuries of its existence the church didn’t make much of Christmas. There was little agreement on when Christ was actually born except everybody accepted that it was almost certainly not on 25th December. In the fourth century the Church took over an already existing Pagan festival which contained all the kinds of excesses the Puritans, centuries later, opposed and attempted to convert it, along with the pagans, to Christianity; one has to say with only limited success. Pagan overindulgence is with us to this day. That said, what links the pagan festival and the Christian festival is a common idea - the idea of light overcoming darkness. Long before the Christian takeover, people realised that the days became shorter and shorter until the third week in December and thereafter the days began to slowly get longer. Thus it was believed that the Sun gradually died as winter deepened and was then reborn reaching its full strength in summer. Pagan rituals involved magic the aim of which was to encourage the sun to regain in strength. In a clever play on words the Church used this sun ritual imagery to announce the rising of the Sun of Righteousness, Jesus Christ.
Of course light overcoming darkness is also a Biblical theme. Isaiah proclaims, “The people who walked in darkness have seen a great light; those who lived in the land of deep darkness – on them light has shined.” (Isaiah 9: 2) Isaiah goes on to predict the coming of a child who will have great authority and will be called “Wonderful Counsellor, Mighty God, Everlasting Father, Prince of Peace.” Now of course Isaiah was addressing the political situation of his own day but the authors of the New Testament, seeing beyond the immediate situation that the prophet spoke about, applied his words to the birth of Jesus. For St Luke and St Matthew the child referred to by Isaiah is none other than the child “wrapped in bands of cloth, lying in a manger”, as the angels announced to the shepherds; the child to whom the Wise Men are led by a star. As the glory of God illuminated the night sky with the angelic announcement and the appearing of the brightest of all stars so this child was born to illuminate the hearts and minds of countless individuals throughout the ages; in fact potentially everybody. St John in the prologue to his gospel does not give us stories about shepherds and kings or for that matter a miraculous virgin birth, rather he talks, like Isaiah, in terms of darkness and light. “In Him was life, and the life was the light of men. The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome it.” (John 2: 4-5) John goes on to say, “The true light that enlightens every man was coming into the world.” (John 1: 9)
Now we can find ourselves, figuratively speaking, in darkness for a multitude of reasons. Like in the days of Isaiah darkness can envelop us due to external circumstances. Darkness can also come as an internal reality when we refuse to acknowledge our true state of being. Whether it is external circumstances or internal denial or a complex mixture of both that is the cause, the outcome is much the same – we can feel as if we are staggering around in the dark not being able to see the way forward. Darkness is a powerful image indeed. Physically speaking being in a darkened room, particularly a room with which we are unfamiliar can be a frightening experience. We can blunder around bumping into things not knowing what they are or what they might possibly be for if anything. We experience danger and its associated fear and often unwanted injury. However if we find the light switch and turn it on we start to see clearly, after perhaps being initially dazzled for a moment or two. Things become clear - oh, that thing I barked my shins on is a coffee table, that thing I fell over is a chair! Now I can sit down and enjoy a coffee.
Sometimes of course it is not as easy as that to find the light switch which, when activated, will illuminate our lives, but St John points us to where it is located. “The true light that enlightens every man was coming into the world.” (John 1: 9) St John seems to be saying that the reality, the light which was seen in history in the life of Jesus, is also within in you. The light which is potentially within everyone was openly manifest in the life of Jesus for all to see. If this is true it follows that, if we care to look, the answer to our own darkness, however that darkness may manifest itself, is to be found within us. Of course not everyone chooses to acknowledge this and if this is true of you and me then we run the risk of remaining in spiritual darkness, going round and round and getting nowhere fast, bumping into things of which we are fearful. Many today see the Christmas story as similar to tales of Santa Claus, good for children but having no reality in a harsh world. I would contend with all who would want to treat the Christmas story thus for at the very least the story of the infant Christ, who is for Christians the light of the world, is the story of an archetypal figure pointing to the divine possibility within us all. The image of the divine child indicates a new beginning: a potential that can grow to maturity from a fragile start, the merest flickering of a light which can become a mighty illuminating flame.
So this Christmastide there may be no magic solutions and instant remedies to the ills that beset you and the world about you. You cannot summon the sun to rise again as the pagans of old attempted to do in the Winter Solstice. But there is an enduring and sustaining hope. The breaking news is not bad news. The light lies deep within you waiting to be expressed. May we all discover and acknowledge the divine spark within each of us this morning. May we allow the light of the internal Christ to illuminate our circumstances and our very selves. May that flickering flame, by God’s grace, show us the way forward in the coming year, leading us to reverse the darkness within us and around us so that we may ourselves be found to be sons and daughters of God.